|
The nose's unheralded neighbor
Study reveals that maxillary sinuses conveniently make room for different nose shapesaccording to climate temperature.
by Richard C. Lewis
Pity the poor maxillary sinuses. Those bulbous pouches on either side of the human nose are known more for trapping mucus and causing sinus infections than anything else. They were thought to be an evolutionary relic of our distant past, with little known present value. Yet researchers led by the University of Iowa believe the unheralded maxillary sinuses play a fortuitous, integral role in the shape and function of the human nose, even today.
After studying faces of African and European origin, the
University of Iowa team has concluded that the maxillary
sinuses act as a cushion of sorts, changing their size
to make room for the nose and to maximize its primary
function, which is to make air as breathable as possible.
The researchers explain the interconnectedness of the maxillary sinuses and the shape of the nasal cavity for the first time in a paper published in the journal The Anatomical Record.
The maxillary sinuses “allow the nose to change shape without affecting other areas of the face,” explains Nathan Holton, a biological anthropologist at the University of Iowa and lead author on the paper. “When something is under selective pressure like the nose, that’s a good thing.”
The maxillary sinuses and the nose share the same wall,
like neighbors in a duplex. Whether they are on good terms
or at odds is important, because the nose needs to be able
to assume different shapesand change that shape without
shifting everything else in the face and craniumto
maximize its function depending on the climate.
Put more simply, the human nose has evolved over time
depending on the type of climate where humans have lived.
In colder places, the nose has evolved to be narrower and
longer, the better to trap air in the nasal passage and warm
and moisten it, which is exactly how the lungs like it.
In warmer climates, the nose is broader and shorter,
because the air generally already is warm and moist and
so the goal is to transport it quickly to the lungs,
rather than let it reside in the nasal passages.
That explains, broadly speaking, the long, prominent bent of
the typical northern European nose and the flatter, broader
shape of the African nose. The maxillary sinuses have been
around as long as the nose, but it's been unclear why.
The team sought to better understand the relationship by taking computed tomography scans of 40 living people, divided evenly between African and European ancestry. The researchers first wanted to find out whether a larger nose would mean smaller maxillary sinuses, and vice versa. To their surprise, that was not the case.
"What we found is that a bigger nasal volume was associated with a bigger sinus volume in both African and European samples," Holton explains. "This is best explained as an overall size dynamic. Individuals with a bigger face also have a bigger nasal cavity and bigger maxillary sinuses."
The team figured then that nose shape must play a more pronounced role than previously thought. The researchers'
mapped the shape of the nasal cavity in the participants by
plotting points at different spots in a grid.
They found that maxillary sinuses in the European-derived
participants were, on average, 36 percent larger than those
in African-origin participants, in faces of roughly the same
size. The reason: Europeans, with their narrower noses,
have more room for maxillary sinuses.
“Essentially, by having these sinuses, that’s what allows the nose to change its shape, at least in terms of width and independently from other parts of the face,” says Holton, who will be named an assistant professor in the orthodontics department at the College of Dentistry in June.
That’s important when considering that the nose needs to change according to where our ancestors lived, with the maxillary sinuses graciously acting as “zones of accommodation,” as the researchers put it.
“Our results suggest that while the sinuses are unlikely to play a direct role in nasorespiratory function, they are important with regard to accommodation of climatically relevant changes in internal nasal shape,” the authors write.
Lauren Butaric from Texas A&M University and Todd Yokley from Metropolitan State University of Denver are co-authors on the paper, first published online last month. The National Science Foundation (grant no: BCS-0550036) and the Leakey Foundation supported the research.
Original article: http://now.uiowa.edu/2013/03/noses-unheralded-neighbor
|